Top

A Small Beginning: origins of the Richard III Society

A Small Beginning: origins of the Richard III Society

by John Saunders

Perhaps inevitably, the events following the discovery of Richard III’s remains in Leicester have rather overshadowed the 90th anniversary of the historical society founded in his name. This article seeks to remedy this and explain particularly to newer members how and why the Richard III Society began.

To do that we need to go back to 1924: during this year the first Labour government in Britain came to power in February under Ramsey McDonald and lasted until the autumn, when the Conservatives led by Stanley Baldwin, returned to office. In the wider world Lenin died in Moscow, Calvin Coolidge was re-elected President of the United States and the summer Olympics were held in Paris. A more unusual event, hardly noticed at the time, took place in England during the late summer; a society was formed for an English king who had been dead for 439 years.

It all began in the village of Northwood at The Gate House, home of the Bacon family. The property straddled two counties and stood on Pinner Hill. The house itself was firmly in Hertfordshire but part of the garden lay in Middlesex; the Post Office deemed it all in the latter. The house had been built in 1919 on land that once formed a part of the Pinner Estate. The encroaching Metropolitan Line had not yet lost the area to surburbia, It was still rural Middlesex, still recognisable as Betjeman’s ‘lost Elysium’.

The Bacon family had recently moved south from their native north-west after the head of the family, Sewell Bacon, retired from running his Liverpool based business. On a day towards the end of August they were entertaining some friends visiting Liverpool. It was a balmy English summer’s evening and after a hearty meal the Bacons and their guests sat out on the veranda to enjoy after dinner drinks and good conversation. Their guests were Samuel Saxon Barton and Dr Philip Nelson, who were both enthusiastic amateur antiquarians with a particular interest in late medieval history.

The Bacons’ youngest son, the 17 year old Patrick, was sitting out in the evening air with his parents and their guests; he was on his summer holidays from school in Rugby. Many years later he recalled the atmosphere of the evening’s conversation: ‘I was listening enthralled because the subject into which they tore with zest and knowledge was King Richard III.’ Patrick himself loved history – it was the only subject that came alive for him at school, and here he was witnessing a passionate debate about the most controversial monarch in English history. Both Barton and Nelson firmly held to the revisionist view of the king, believing that the last Plantagenet had been harshly and unfairly dealt with by history. In the heat of the discussion the suggestion was made that they form a society for promote the revisionist cause and encourage research into the life and times of King Richard. There seems little doubt that it was Saxon Barton who uttered the genesis words ‘Let’s form a society’. In a letter he wrote many years later he quite specifically refers to himself as the one who ‘started off to form this Society’. The idea met with an enthusiastic response: it was decided that Barton would be secretary, Nelson the treasurer, and the young Patrick Bacon the first member. They called themselves ‘The Fellowship of the White Boar’, and so it began.

The early years of the Fellowship are not easy to chronicle. There were no formal structures, minutes, membership records or publications. They were never more than a small circle of friends and acquaintances and did not actively seek a wider membership base. New members were more the result of serendipity than strategy. Saxon Barton, as secretary, was undoubtedly the lynchpin. However, they were a group of strong individuals, talented in their own fields, and what they did achieve with limited resources is worthy of record. They undertook research and engaged in public debate about King Richard, particularly during the early 1930s, when the contents of the urn in Westminster Abbey were examined and Mancini’s account of events in 1483 were published. In 1934 the Fellowship were instigators of the memorial window to King Richard and his family in Middleham church, which remains one of the most poignant memorials to the king. With the advent of war in 1939 their activities declined and it wasn’t until the 1950s, when Isolde Wigram made contact with Barton, that the Fellowship was revived and relaunched as the Richard III Society. But that’s another story. For now, here’s a little more about the lives of those first three members.

Our founder was born Samuel Saxon Barton in 1892 in the city of Liverpool, the son of Samuel and Jessie Barton. He was educated at schools in Liverpool and at Edinburgh University and trained as a surgeon, specialising in obstetrics and gynaecology. His reputation was established through work at various hospitals in the north-west of England and north Wales. During the First World War he served in the Royal Navy as a surgeon-lieutenant. A posting aboard HMS Dwarf saw Barton serve off the Cameroons and west coast of Africa. During this time he gained an expertise in tropical medicine and later acted as an adviser in this field to the Liverpool office of the Ministry of Pensions. He was awarded the OBE for his wartime service.

Barton was a man of many and varied interests. He was a gifted artist, having been trained by the celebrated Liverpool artist, James A Watts. His paintings were exhibited annually at the Cambrian Academy and the Liver Sketching Club. He also wrote verse, publishing three volumes in his lifetime. Physically he was similar to G K Chesterton, with an extrovert character to match. Patrick Bacon in later years recalled that ‘he had Rabelaisian in the extreme. Perhaps he fooled some people into thinking that he was an arrogant exhibitionist – however, his scholarship was deep and true and he embellished it with a Shavian gusto and passion. He was a fighter who loved to be involved.’ Saxon Barton died in 1957 as a result of a car accident and is buried in Halewood near Liverpool.

Philip Nelson was born in 1872 into a Liverpool ship-owning family. He was educated at schools in Birkenhead and thereafter studied medicine in Liverpool, London and Vienna. A potentially promising career in consultancy practice was cut short by injury to his right arm. Patrick Bacon recalled that he had ‘a smile like an apologetic angel and a wit that burnished with every sentence.’ He was an enthusiastic collector in many fields and had a deep interest in numismatics. His collection included alabasters, historical curiosities and numerous Greek and Roman marbles. Amongst his curios could be found a ring that once belonged to Warwick the Kingmaker and a hair from the head of James I.

Nelson was a recognised expert on cathedral and church windows and his book Ancient Painted Glass in England 1170-1500 was for many years the definitive work on the subject. His expertise in other fields extended to Saxon archaeology and Chaucerian studies. His friendship with Saxon Barton was developed through their mutual membership of the Historic Society of Lancashire and Cheshire. They were both active member, at various times holding the offices of honorary secretary and vice-president.

Nelson died early in 1953 at the age of 81. His obituary notes with feeling that ‘physically and intellectually he was cast in the heroic mould, and few who had the privilege of his friendship failed to be aware of a character that was noble and yet entirely humble.’

Patrick Bacon was born in Lancashire in 1906 and educated at Rugby. He served in intelligence during the Second World War and thereafter pursued a successful career in advertising. Despite being signed up in 1924, Patrick could not recall having much direct involvement with the Fellowship, although he kept in close contact with Barton and Nelson. He did, however, visit the site of the battle of Bosworth during the 1930s and remained committed to the revisionist cause. It was a chance meeting with Isolde Wigram that brought him back into the fold, and when the Fellowship was formally relaunched in 1956 he became its first chairman. His background in advertising and public relations was very helpful to the Society during the formative years of the 1960s. He held the post until his retirement in 1971, when he was succeeded by Jeremy Potter. Following his retirement from the chair, Patrick was elected the Society’s President, a post which had been vacant since Saxon Barton’s death 14 years earlier. Patrick remained President until his own death in 1996, shortly after his 90th birthday.

What sort of historical society did Saxon Barton envisage? There is no doubt he wanted one based on scholarly research, as he noted in a letter from the 1950s: ‘In my view historical belief must be based on facts where possible and on honest conviction.’ What would he think of the Society today? His widow, Dorothy Barton, survived him by many decades, dying shortly before her 100th birthday in 1996. In 1989 she attended the Society’s Bosworth commemorations and wrote to me shortly afterwards and noted ‘How delighted Saxon would be to know that the torch he lit so long ago is not only still burning brightly but is so much strengthened. Long may it continue.’ Some 25 years later I rather suspect he would be even more delighted.

 

This article first appeared in The Ricardian Bulletin, September 2014.

Richard III Society
Privacy Overview

This website uses cookies so that we can provide you with the best user experience possible. Cookie information is stored in your browser and performs functions such as recognising you when you return to our website and helping our team to understand which sections of the website you find most interesting and useful.